Printer Friendly Version
Vol. XIV, No. 6
July 2006

Home Replacement Value


Summary

Over the past several years, several weather-related catastrophes have highlighted the importance of knowing the appropriate value of the family home.  Increases in building materials and labor costs, indirectly due to hurricanes and higher world demand, have caused the replacement value of the family home to rise higher than the general inflation rate.  Homeowners need to adequately protect their single largest asset with a suitable amount of insurance.

A HOME’S VALUE
Over the past several years, several weather-related catastrophes have highlighted the importance of knowing the appropriate value of the family home.  A problem arises because many homeowners confuse "market value" with "replacement value."

  • Market value, which includes the cost of land, is what a buyer will pay for your property.  Using comparables, market trends, seasonality and other readily available data, it's relatively easy to get within a few thousand dollars of calculating a "fair selling price."  From there, market supply and buyer demand determine the final price.
  • Replacement value is much more complicated to figure out.  Typically, replacement value is less than market value (with some exceptions).  The cost to rebuild your home is based on:
    • Local construction costs
    • Square footage of the structure
    • Type of exterior wall construction -- frame, masonry (brick or stone) or veneer
    • Style of the house (ranch, colonial)
    • Number of bathrooms and other rooms
    • Type of roof
    • Attached garages, fireplaces, exterior trim and other special features like arched windows

In addition, factor in your community's building codes, which require buildings to be constructed to minimum standards.  Rebuilding your home to today's standards, especially if you must redesign your home to meet the new standards, will probably cost more than it would to reconstruct it based on the old standards.

A recent report by Marshall & Swift/Boeckh, a Los Angeles firm that tracks building costs, estimates that, in 2004, 61 percent of U.S. homes were undervalued for insurance purposes by an average of 25 percent.
Replacement costs are always more expensive than building new construction – by about 20 to 30 percent.  That's because along with location and regional labor and material costs, you'll likely also need the special services of demolition and debris removal experts.

Higher Building and Labor Costs
Prices for construction materials, which also include lumber and plastics, have been climbing because of demand from overseas and higher energy prices.  And construction companies that might have absorbed price increases in the past are now passing those costs on to their commercial and residential customers.

The increase in construction costs is tied to a variety of factors.  Higher crude oil prices have made the delivery of goods more expensive.  And because oil is used to make plastic pipes and vinyl siding, it has also driven up the costs of those products.  Steel and cement costs have risen due to shortages created by strong demand from overseas markets, especially China.

In December 2005, steel prices were up 4.2 percent from the previous year, and plastics were up 20.6 percent, according to Jim Haughey, the director of economics at Reed Business Information.  Cement was up 12.3 percent and gypsum wall board was up 15.3 percent from the previous year.

Price increases are widespread: supply disruptions related to Hurricanes Rita and Katrina raised prices for PVC pipe, which is used by plumbers for water lines and by electricians for wire conduits (PVC is a byproduct of natural gas).

HOMEOWNERS INSURANCE
Higher material and labor costs have a direct bearing on the amount of insurance coverage a homeowner should have in their homeowners insurance policy.  The policy limit represents the most that can be recovered in the event of total destruction.

No insurance company will permit you to set your limit for more than it would cost to replace your home.  However, you may purchase insurance for less than the replacement amount because of the 80 percent rule, which provides that if you want to collect the full cost of replacing or repairing your house, the amount of insurance you carry at the time of the loss must be at least 80 percent of the full replacement cost of the structure. (Because the cost of homeowners insurance is relatively low, it is recommended that you insure your home to its full replacement value.)  Full replacement cost means what it would cost you today to rebuild in the event of total destruction.  This figure might even exceed the market value of your house if, for example, you have an ornate old Victorian with a lot of detail work that is virtually impossible to duplicate at today's costs.  [Discuss this with your insurance representative if you do have an older, historical home; you may need a special type of insurance policy referred as an HO-8.]

If you do meet the 80 percent test and your house is destroyed, you can recover the full replacement cost up to your policy limit.  If you do not meet the test, your recovery will be less. To illustrate the 80 percent rule: the replacement value of your house is $200,000, which means you are required to have it insured for at least $160,000 if you want the insurance company to cover major damages in full.  Suppose, though, that you decide to save money and buy only $120,000 worth of insurance; as a result, the insurance company will pay only part of your major loss.  That part will be determined by setting up a ratio between what coverage you do have ($120,000) and what the insurance policy says you should have ($160,000).  If you have a major loss, you will only receive three-fourths (75 percent) from the insurance company, minus the deductible.  More words of caution: even if you do meet the 80 percent test, you'll only recover up to your policy limit in the event of total loss.  So it's best to try to achieve 100 percent coverage of the replacement cost.

In most policies, the 80 percent test does not apply to losses smaller than $1,000 or 5 percent of the amount of the insurance you carry.

How can you avoid being underinsured?
Here are some tips to help you obtain an adequate amount of replacement cost insurance for your home:

  • Have your insurance agent or a professional appraiser help you calculate the cost of rebuilding your home in today's market.
  • Ask about total home replacement cost coverage or guaranteed replacement cost coverage.  This option pays you what it costs to rebuild your house at today's construction prices.  Be sure to have replacement cost coverage on your belongings, as well.
  • Ask about an inflation guard, an endorsement that automatically increases your coverage as the value of your home increases.
  • Be sure your homeowners coverage is up-to-date.  Tell your agent about any improvements or additions, as well as any unique architectural features.
  • Maintain an up-to-date inventory of your belongings and keep it in a location away from your home.  This way, you have an accurate record of what is in your home – instead of relying on your memory of what each room contained when filing a claim.  It’s best to videotape your property inside (and outside) your home.

NEA MEMBER BENEFITS
NEA members can obtain home insurance coverage from either the NEA Homeowners Program, underwritten by Horace Mann Insurance Company, or the NEA Members Auto & Home Insurance Program, underwritten by California Casualty Insurance Company.  Find out more by visiting www.neamb.com or calling toll free, 1-800-637-4636, Monday – Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. (or Saturday, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.) ET.

# # #

 
| Home | NEA | About NEA MB | Member Services | Privacy Policy | Search | NEA Seal of Excellence |
 
www.neamb.com | e-mail: ask-us@neamb.com | 1-800-637-4636
Nosotros Hablamos Español —Para mas información sobre beneficios, Productos y Servicios de
NEA por favor llame al Centro de Servicio para Miembros al 1-800-637-4636 y pida hablar con un representante que hable Español.

Copyright © 2008 NEA Member Benefits. All rights reserved.