5 Myths About Credit Cards

Don’t fall for these commonly held misconceptions.

Credit Card Myths - Woman Holding a Credit Card and Thinking

by NEA Member Benefits


Credit cards can be indispensable financial tools, but you may be receiving mixed messages about how to use them wisely. Consumer knowledge about credit matters has steadily declined over the past eight years, according to the latest annual survey by the Consumer Federation of America.

To help clarify fact from fiction, here are five of the most common credit card myths—debunked.

Myth #1: You only need one credit card

Reality: It’s always wise to apply for credit judiciously, of course, as applying for multiple cards in quick succession can cause your credit score to drop. But if you already use credit responsibly, there are valid reasons why having more than one card might make sense. Here are three to consider:

  • You’ll have a backup. What if your credit card becomes compromised due to fraud or is declined? Having another card on hand can provide backup and give you peace of mind. Plus, having an additional card means you’ll have an option if a merchant doesn’t accept the one you carry.
  • You can maximize rewards. Another benefit of carrying more than one card is taking advantage of rewards plans that fit your spending patterns. For example, you could use a card that offers the best grocery rewards to do all your food shopping, use a top-rated travel rewards card to book Airbnb reservations, or use a designated card only for reimbursable job-related expenses.
  • You can better manage debt. Different credit cards have different purposes and choosing one that helps you meet financial goals may provide important advantages. For example, as an NEA member, you may choose to apply for the NEA RateSmart® Card which can help you save on interest and pay down debt when you transfer higher-rate balances.

Myth #2: Making the minimum monthly payment is enough

Reality: Last year, 35% of adults surveyed for the FINRA Investor Education Foundation’s latest National Financial Capability Study said they paid only the minimum payment (typically between 1% and 3% of your balance) on their credit cards in some months. The problem? The higher the balance you carry from month to month, the more interest you pay. And that’s money you could be saving or using for other things.

What’s more, if you continue paying only the minimum repeatedly, the interest compounds. Let’s say you have a credit card balance of $7,800 with an interest rate of 15%. You’re currently making a 3% minimum payment of $234 each month. It would take three-and-a-half years to repay that debt entirely—plus you’d end up paying $2,353 in interest.

Ultimately, there’s only one guaranteed way to avoid paying interest on purchases. If possible, pay off the balance every month.

Myth #3: All rewards programs are the same

Reality: No single rewards card is a perfect match for everyone.

Rewards credit cards essentially come in two flavors: cash-back cards and travel cards. Cash-back cards pay you back a percentage of each transaction—usually between 1% and 6%. Travel rewards cards, on the other hand, give you points or miles for each dollar you spend. The points are redeemable for airline flights or hotel stays, among other things.

Around 33% of credit cards with rewards give cash back, while 63% provide points or miles, according to a recent WalletHub analysis. And each card comes with various caps, expirations, rebate levels, sign-up bonuses and spending categories.

What’s the best way to make cards with perks work for you? Decide exactly how you plan to use them. Here are two factors to consider:

  • Estimate the true value. Assess the likelihood of what the rewards you expect to receive (and will actually use) are worth each year, compared to the annual fee you must pay.
  • Customize rewards based on your needs. Earning cash back on categories that match your spending makes financial sense. That means it’s wise to look for flexibility.

Here’s an example of that kind of flexibility. With the NEA® Cash Rewards Card, available to NEA members, you can tailor your rewards based on your personal situation and spending plans. You can earn 3% cash back in any one of six categories—gas, online shopping, dining, travel, drug stores, or home improvement/ furnishings—and you can change the category once a month. Plus, you’ll earn 2% cash back at grocery stores and wholesale clubs, and 1% on all other purchases. You can earn 3% and 2% cash back on the first $2,500 you spend in your combined choice category and grocery store/wholesale club purchases each quarter.

Say you’re planning a vacation road trip during the last part of summer break and anticipate dining out a lot more. You could choose to earmark your future 3% rewards for the month to the “Dining” category to maximize your cash back.

Myth #4: A high credit card limit is a bad thing

Reality: On the contrary, having a higher credit limit that’s managed appropriately may have a positive impact on your credit score.

In most cases, a higher limit indicates that credit-reporting agencies consider you a favorable risk. But if you routinely use a large percentage of your available credit, they may interpret it to mean just the opposite—that you’re overextended—and a less favorable risk. That’s why it’s important to manage a high credit limit wisely.

Here’s how: Part of your credit score depends on the amount of credit you have versus the amount you’ve used—known as the credit utilization ratio. You can calculate your ratio by dividing your total credit card balances by your credit limits. As a guideline, experts often recommend using 30% or less of available credit—to show that you can keep your balances low in proportion to your overall credit limit. For example, if your credit limit is $3,000, you’d want to try to keep an average balance of no more than $1,000.

So, if you’ve had a credit card for a while and have demonstrated consistent, on-time payments without getting too close to your credit limit, it may be a good idea to ask the credit card company to raise the limit (which can help lower utilization).

Myth #5: You need to carry a balance to build credit

Reality: A majority of credit users (54%) surveyed by NerdWallet believe that carrying a monthly balance improves their credit score—which is incorrect. In fact, having high outstanding debt can negatively affect your credit score.

To build a healthy credit history, pay attention to the factors that go into calculating your credit score (such as FICO® or VantageScore). Components of a FICO® Score, for example, are divided into five weighted categories: payment history (35%), amounts owed (30%), length of credit history (15%), new credit (10%) and credit mix (10%).

In general, having credit cards, making payments on time and limiting credit utilization will all help build your credit scores. Someone with no credit cards, for example, tends to be viewed as higher risk than someone who has managed credit cards responsibly over time.

Build credit success

As you explore credit card options, consider leveraging current connections. Depending on the reason for adding a card, for example, you may want to start comparison-shopping with your current card provider, bank, credit union or professional membership group. Why? Your existing relationship may qualify you for a better offer.

You can learn more about choosing a credit card and discover NEA-member cards that offer competitive rates and rewards here.

Find the NEA credit card that’s right for you